The Twa Sisters

The Twa Sisters is a traditional folk song that has been a part of various cultures around the world for centuries. Known by several names, including "The Two Sisters" and "Binnorie," this ballad tells the story of sibling rivalry that ends in tragedy. It is classified in the Francis James Child collection of English and Scottish Popular Ballads as Child Ballad number 10.

Synopsis

The song narrates the story of two sisters, the elder of whom is jealous of the younger. In most versions, the narrative revolves around a suitor who prefers the younger sister over the elder. Driven by jealousy, the elder sister lures the younger to a body of water and pushes her in, leading to the younger sister's death. The body is discovered and, in many variations, a musician crafts an instrument from the corpse, typically a harp or a fiddle, which then sings the tale of the murder.

Themes and Analysis

The Twa Sisters is rich in themes of jealousy, betrayal, and supernatural justice. The ballad explores the dark side of human nature through the lens of familial relationships, highlighting the extreme lengths to which jealousy can drive individuals. The supernatural element, where the younger sister's death is avenged through music, suggests themes of truth and justice prevailing beyond the grave.

Variants and History

The ballad has numerous variants across different cultures, indicating its widespread popularity and adaptation over the centuries. The story's core elements remain consistent, though details and settings may vary. The Scottish version, often called "Binnorie," and the Scandinavian variants are among the most well-known. The song's enduring appeal can be attributed to its dramatic narrative and the universal themes it encompasses.

Cultural Impact

The Twa Sisters has had a significant impact on folk music, inspiring countless renditions and adaptations by folk musicians and scholars. Its narrative has also influenced literature and the arts, serving as a source of inspiration for writers, composers, and artists intrigued by its themes of envy, murder, and supernatural retribution.

See Also

• Francis James Child
• Child Ballads
• Folk Music
• Sibling Rivalry