Pit of despair

A rhesus monkey infant in one of Harlow's isolation chambers. The photograph was taken when the chamber door was raised for the first time after six months of total isolation.

Harlow's vertical chamber apparatus

Pit of despair is a term that refers to an experimental apparatus created by American comparative psychologist Harry Harlow in the 1950s. The device was designed to study the effects of social isolation on primates, particularly rhesus macaque monkeys, which are highly social animals. The research aimed to understand the importance of caregiving and companionship to mental and social development. Harlow's work, while groundbreaking, has been widely criticized for ethical reasons.

Background

Harry Harlow's interest in the effects of social isolation stemmed from his earlier work on the maternal-separation, dependency needs, and social isolation experiments with rhesus monkeys. This work was pivotal in understanding the nature of attachment theory. Before Harlow's experiments, the dominant thought in psychology was that physical needs (such as hunger) were the most important factors in mother-child bonding. Harlow's findings challenged this view, emphasizing the importance of care, love, and social connections.

Design and Methodology

The pit of despair was a vertical chamber, also known as the "well of despair," made of stainless steel and designed to isolate the monkey from all social contact. The chamber was equipped with a feeding bottle and a waste removal system to minimize the need for human contact. Monkeys were placed in the chamber alone after being separated from their mothers at an early age, for periods ranging from 30 days to one year.

Findings

The experiments conducted using the pit of despair revealed profound effects on the subjects. Monkeys subjected to isolation exhibited severe psychological disturbances, including depression, anxiety, and antisocial behavior upon reintroduction to the social group. Some of the isolated monkeys were unable to integrate into monkey society and displayed behaviors such as blank staring, circling their cages, and self-mutilation. Harlow's work demonstrated the importance of social and emotional development in primates, suggesting parallels in human development.

Ethical Considerations

The ethical implications of Harlow's experiments have been a subject of intense debate. Critics argue that the psychological harm inflicted on the animals was inhumane and that the knowledge gained did not justify the means. The pit of despair experiments are frequently cited in discussions on animal welfare in research, leading to increased scrutiny and ethical standards in the treatment of animals in scientific studies.

Impact on Psychology

Despite the ethical controversies, Harlow's work had a significant impact on psychology. It contributed to a greater understanding of the importance of early social interactions, the development of attachment, and the psychological effects of isolation and deprivation. His experiments influenced the fields of child development, attachment theory, and social psychology, highlighting the complex interplay between biological needs and social relationships.

See Also

• Animal welfare
• Ethics in animal experimentation
• Social isolation
• Attachment theory
• Child development

‎