Trick or Treatment?

Cover of Trick or Treatment book

Trick or Treatment? Alternative Medicine on Trial is a book that critically examines the evidence for and against alternative therapies. Authored by Simon Singh, a British author, and Edzard Ernst, a professor of Complementary Medicine, the book aims to scrutinize the scientific validity of various alternative medicine practices. Published in 2008, Trick or Treatment? has sparked discussions and debates within both the medical community and the general public regarding the efficacy and safety of alternative treatments.

Summary

Trick or Treatment? is divided into several chapters, each dedicated to exploring a different area of alternative medicine, including Acupuncture, Homeopathy, Chiropractic therapy, and Herbal medicine. The authors employ a rigorous scientific approach to evaluate the claims made by proponents of these therapies. They delve into the history of each practice, discuss its theoretical basis, and then examine the available scientific evidence regarding its effectiveness. The book also addresses the placebo effect, the ethics of promoting unproven treatments, and the dangers of relying on alternative therapies over conventional medical practices.

Critical Reception

The reception of Trick or Treatment? has been largely positive, especially among the scientific and medical communities. Critics have praised the book for its thorough research, clear presentation, and commitment to evidence-based medicine. However, it has also faced criticism from practitioners and advocates of alternative medicine, who argue that the book is biased and dismisses anecdotal evidence of the effectiveness of these therapies.

Impact

Since its publication, Trick or Treatment? has influenced public opinion and policy regarding alternative medicine. It has been cited in debates on the regulation of alternative therapies and has contributed to a more skeptical and questioning approach among patients considering these treatments. The book has also been used as a textbook in medical and health sciences courses to teach critical thinking and the importance of evidence-based practice.

See Also

• Evidence-based medicine
• Placebo effect
• Scientific skepticism
• Health fraud