Cluttering

Cluttering is a communication disorder characterized by speech that is challenging to comprehend due to its rapid pace, erratic rhythm, and the frequent use of inappropriate syntax or grammar.

Classification

Often categorized as a fluency disorder, cluttering stands distinct from other speech disorders. The formal definition states:

"Cluttering is a fluency disorder characterized by a rate perceived as abnormally rapid, irregular, or both for the speaker. Rate abnormalities manifest in: (a) an excessive number of disfluencies not typical of stuttering; (b) frequent placement of pauses and prosodic patterns inconsistent with syntactic and semantic constraints; and (c) inappropriate coarticulation, especially in multisyllabic words."

Signs and Symptoms

Contrary to common belief, "stuttering" does not encompass all types of speech dysfluency. In fact, what many people label as stuttering in day-to-day nervous speech might actually resemble cluttering more closely.

While both cluttering and stuttering disrupt the flow of speech, they have different underlying issues. Stutterers generally think coherently but face challenges vocalizing these thoughts. Clutterers, on the other hand, can easily form words for their thoughts, but these thoughts tend to become muddled during verbal expression. Cluttering influences various modes of communication, including thought patterns, writing, typing, and general conversation.

Distinguishing features of cluttering include:

Clear speech at the beginning of sentences, which becomes faster and less intelligible as the sentence progresses. An absence of the "struggle behaviors" seen in stutterers, such as tension in speech production muscles. Often effortless, with slurred speech, particularly mispronounced /r/ and /l/ sounds. Monotonal speech that begins audibly but fades into a murmur. One individual with cluttering described the experience as:

"It feels like multiple thoughts bombard my mind simultaneously, demanding immediate expression. Often, while making a point, a prior relevant thought occurs to me, prompting self-interruption. There's a constant need to revise sentences to get them right."

Differential Diagnosis

Cluttering shares symptoms with other conditions, leading to possible misdiagnoses. These conditions include language delay, language disorder, learning disabilities, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Many clutterers also display reading and writing challenges, typified by sprawling, disorganized handwriting that fails to effectively merge ideas and spatial considerations.

Treatment

A significant challenge in treating cluttering stems from the patient's limited awareness of their disorder, which can result in indifference or even aversion to intervention from speech-language pathologists. Delayed auditory feedback (DAF) is a common therapeutic technique used to elicit a more intentional, pronounced oral-motor response. Comprehensive treatment may also encompass narrative structure improvement using storytelling picture books, practicing turn-taking, pausing exercises, and targeted language therapy.

See Also

• Stuttering
• Speech-language pathology
• Communication disorders

Cluttering Resources
Latest articles Most recent articles Ongoing trials	Wikipedia